Skip to content

Metal AM: Challenging the Paradigm

Will Hasting Director of Aviation and Power Turbine Solutions VELO3D
By Will Hasting Director of Aviation and Power Turbine Solutions, Velo3D

Manufacturing Engineering: VELO3D has trademarked the term “SupportFree.” What does this mean and what kind of cost savings or improved part quality can shops expect from using your technology?

AM-Update-Lead-768x432.jpg
This engine combustor from Sierra Turbines previously required 61 discrete components to manufacture, but thanks to SupportFree technology, can now be 3D-printed in a single operation.

Will Hasting: The industry standard for 3D printing metal surfaces [without supports] is 45 degrees, as measured from the horizontal plane. That’s what most printers are capable of achieving without supports. This means, however, that any features shallower than this require a support or series of supports to prevent curling and distortion. These [support] structures must then be removed post-build, adding to cost and lead-time, and possibly jeopardizing part quality.

By comparison, we can successfully print surfaces down to 10 degrees and, in some cases, actually 0 degrees, or completely horizontal. That’s a huge differentiator, especially for parts with complex internal features, where it’s difficult or even impossible to remove these supports. Sometimes the printing process is truly support-free, where the parts are free-floating in powder, and other times, it is support-less, which means it reduces the consideration of support structures for manufacturing.

ME: Similarly, does support-free printing open doors in terms of design freedom or ease the manufacturing process in any way?

Hasting: SupportFree reduces the natural tension between design and engineering. It enables designers to think and build without constraints, and gives engineers greater latitude to extract more performance from their products and systems. For example, we recently worked with Sierra Turbines here in San Jose on an engine combustor that previously required 61 discrete components to manufacture. Because we can print at extremely low angles, we can eliminate the supports that otherwise would have been required. The result is greater aerodynamic efficiency and less air leakage. You also have a more consistent, repeatable structure, with fine meshes and smooth lattice structures that provide better fuel flow to the combustion chamber. There’s no way this part could have been manufactured without SupportFree printing in its current iteration.

ME: Are there any downsides to this approach? Slower build speeds? Higher equipment or operating costs? More challenging build preparation?

Hasting: That’s an interesting question. For operating costs, we made a back-to-back comparison on an impeller printed with and without supports. With the latter, we used 14 percent less powder, had a 20 percent faster print time, and were left with 89 percent less surface area to machine.

And yet there’s more to it than the build. SupportFree not only means greater design freedom but also less engineering time. In fact, we just spoke with one of our machine shop customers, Duncan Machine Products in Oklahoma, who told us our machine is very intuitive, far more so than CNC machining. Our system is easier to use because we know the paradigms and obstacles that have historically prevented metal AM adoption.

ME: Support elimination is clearly essential for parts with large numbers of complex internal features, as evident from your success with heat exchanger and gas turbine manufacturers, but is it as relevant with simpler parts, where secondary finishing processes can easily remove these supports?

Hasting: We at VELO3D take pride in our ability to tackle the tough parts that others can’t, but that doesn’t mean we’re not competitive on simpler parts as well. The Sapphire system prints with greater consistency and higher yield rates while eliminating all sorts of issues and problems commonly encountered on 3D metal printers. Parts of all shapes and sizes are simply more printable.

ME: Most metal 3D printer manufacturers tout their in-process build monitoring and environmental control capabilities. What makes VELO3D’s technology different?

Hasting: We designed a system that’s engineered with far more sensors and provides more insight into the build process. The data is actionable and informative, versus accumulating terabytes of data without much usability. We also developed a software suite that knocks down obstacles that might keep us from printing what we need to print, whether it’s a problem with the material, the part geometry, or a hardware constraint. The Assure system gives our customers access to all the tools and data we used to develop the Sapphire 3D printer, providing insight into the build process. And while all 3D printers generate data, you have to look at how usable this data is to the technicians and engineers using the system.

ME: You recently introduced a large-format 3D metal printer, said to be the tallest such machine available. Was this simply a matter of increasing the height of the build chamber and adding Z-axis travel?

Hasting: The Sapphire 1MZ has a 1-m high build chamber and provides the same level of process control as the original Sapphire metal 3D printer. It’s receiving a lot of attention from rocket and defense manufacturers and those in the oil and gas industry since it gives them the capability to combine assemblies that previously required welding and fitting of multiple components. This will be the case with Knust-Godwin in Katy, Texas, which is looking forward to delivery of the first 1MZ later this year.

ME: The VELO3D website claims that your Flow software “unlocks parts not previously possible with additive manufacturing.” How so?

Hasting: We’ve already discussed part complexity, so let’s focus on scalability and repeatability. Complete software and hardware integration is one of the key aspects of our technology. If you used a PC back in the 1990s, you know that the hardware and software typically came from different manufacturers. The two would often fight, and the user had to trick the system to get everything working. That situation is similar to many of the 3D printers today, and it’s what impressed me most when I first came to VELO3D—everything is integrated. You can print a part today and six months from now send that same Flow file to a printer anywhere in the world. The results will be the same, regardless of part quantity, the machine vintage, and the serial number on the laser.

ME: Metal AM has taken off over the past 10 years. What will happen in the next decade?

Hasting: One thing is parts are still too expensive, and much of that is due to post-processing costs. VELO3D has already addressed this and will continue to push our technology farther to reduce support structures and also [increase] part quality in terms of first-time yield. But what is really holding metal AM back is confidence in the parts.

For instance, a company’s metal AM team might want to use additive to make a part, but the chief engineer won’t sign off on it. Some of that reluctance is because it’s a relatively new technology, but it’s also because manufacturers have been burned with the lack of process control in most metal AM systems. They lack confidence, and the only way to get it is through traceable process data, leading to better part quality and successful build experiences. Over the coming years, that’s what we will continue to provide.

Signicast Partners with DDM

Investment casting company Signicast, Hartford, Wis., a Form Technologies company, has signed a partnership with DDM Digital Foundry, Atlanta, a digital manufacturer that uses its LAMP (large area maskless photopolymerization) ceramic 3D printing technology to produce investment castings. The agreement promises to give Signicast and DDM customers the ability to create more ergonomic components with less material cost and shorter lead times. “DDM is proud to join hands with Signicast to modernize investment casting while offering speed, complexity and value to customers. This partnership greatly accelerates the introduction of DDM’s ceramic 3D printing-based Digital Foundry offering to the market,” said Suman Das, founder and CEO of DDM.

Desktop Metal Goes Public

AM-Update-2.jpg
Desktop Metal’s ‘office friendly’ Studio System.

Through a business agreement with global credit investment firm Trine Acquisition Corp., New York, N.Y., Desktop Metal, Burlington, Mass., is receiving up to $575 million to grow the company. Upon completion of the transaction, the combined operating company will be named Desktop Metal Inc. and will trade on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker symbol DM.

AM to Generate $4.2 Billion in Footwear

A new report by SmarTech Analysis, Crozet, Va., projects that additive manufacturing in the footwear market will generate more than $4.2 billion in annual revenues in 2025. The report also noted that the footwear business—where 3D printing has been used for prototyping—is a good example of AM’s revenue potential in such mass markets. And while UV-based vat polymerization will remain the dominant AM process in the footwear industry over the next decade, the report predicts that powder-based fusion (PBF) will play a growing role, pulling nearly even by 2028 with $154 million in annual equipment sales.

ExOne Qualifies Inconel 718

AM-Update-3.jpg
With its recent superalloy addition, Inconel 718, ExOne’s material list now includes 22 materials.

The ExOne Co., North Huntingdon, Pa., a manufacturer of industrial sand and metal 3D printers using binder jetting technology, recently announced that the nickel-based alloy Inconel 718 has been certified as Third-Party Qualified, the company’s highest designation of material readiness for its metal 3D printers. “Today’s qualification of Inconel 718, following on the heels of M2 Tool Steel earlier this year, shows the ExOne R&D team is aggressively delivering new materials for binder jet 3D printing,” said Rick Lucas, ExOne CTO and vice president, new markets. “Our increasing pace of material qualifications is a testament to the strength of our new metal 3D printer systems equipped with Triple ACT, an advanced compaction technology that is essential for binder jetting metals and other materials at high speeds and densities.”

Siemens Outlines Additive Manufacturing Success Stories

The technology market research firm ARC Advisory Group Inc., Dedham, Mass., recently spoke with representatives from Siemens Digital Industries Software, Plano, Texas, who shared several customer success stories regarding the company’s NX software suite and its design for additive manufacturing (DFAM) capabilities:

  • Piper Aircraft switched from externally sourced production tools to in-house production using 3D printers. This shortened engineering time and lowered production costs for hundreds of tools per year.
  • BMW optimized the production of 100,000 custom parts per year at the company’s own AM campus. The parts are custom printed for personalized cars.
  • Toolcraft, a supplier of precision parts, tools and injection molds, used Siemens NX to reduce the weight of a mold by 50 percent and production time by 30 percent using conformal cooling.
  • A manufacturer of gas turbine burners reduced manufacturing time from 32 weeks to three weeks. The company used Siemens NX software to optimize the design of the burners by eliminating the need for an external pipe through a hollow casting, thus making the 3D printing job much faster.

The company also discussed its partnerships with machine builder DMG Mori, which supports the use of Siemens’ AM technology in its LASERTEC 65 3D hybrid machine, and ExOne, which used Siemens digital twin technology to develop a new 3D printer, the S-Max Pro.

Next-Gen Automated Machine To Enable Production Repair of Turbine Blades

AM-Update-4.jpg
F-35A-Lightning-II fighter jets. The U.S. Air Force awarded Optomec a contract for an AM machine to refurbish turbine engine components.

The U.S. Air Force awarded Optomec Inc., Albuquerque, N.M., a $1 million contract to deliver a high-volume production machine for refurbishing turbine engine components, including titanium parts. The equipment will include a range of capabilities, such as an automation system for batch processing, an oxygen-free controlled atmosphere, and an adaptive vision system. This automated additive repair system will be capable of processing tens of thousands of repairs per year, with an initial focus on tip refurbishment for turbine blades. Optomec will also assist the Air Force in developing optimal process parameters for a range of target repairs. The solution will be installed at Tinker Air Force Base, Oklahoma City.

  • View All Articles
  • Connect With Us
    TwitterFacebookLinkedInYouTube

Related Articles

Webinars, White Papers and More!

SME's Manufacturing Resource Center keeps you updated on all of the latest industry trends and information. Access unlimited FREE webinars, white papers, eBooks, case studies and reports now!